DCA Score
What do the 21 rules test, and what does a score of 70 mean?
DCA stands for Durable Competitive Advantage: a business that can hold its prices and its returns for years. The score is the share of our 21 quality rules that a company passes, counted only over the rules that apply to it. Nothing is ever subtracted. Points are added up and divided by the number of rules judged, so the score cannot fall below zero.
The formula
DCA Score = Points earned ÷ Rules that apply × 100
- A rule: One test on one number, with a level it has to clear. The 21 sit in three groups, exactly as the page lists them: Income Statement, rules 1 to 8. Balance Sheet, rules 9 to 20. Cash Flow, rule 21. So the score leans almost entirely on what a company earns and what it holds. Exactly one rule reads the cash flow statement, which is why the Cash Flow chapter is mostly numbers you read yourself rather than numbers the score is built on.
- Points earned: Every rule that applies is judged twice, on the newest quarter and on the five-year average. Both pass, the rule scores a full point. One passes, half a point. Neither passes, nothing.
- A clear fail: Some rules carry a second, much worse level. That check runs first, before the two halves are counted: if the newest reading crosses it, the rule scores nothing, even if the five-year half passed. So it costs that half point. That is its only effect, and it is the whole of it.
- Rules that apply: Only the rules that make sense for this kind of company. A rule that does not apply is dropped from the top of the sum and the bottom, so it can neither help nor hurt.
Example
Two imaginary companies. Some rules make no sense for either kind of business and are dropped, so Company A is judged on 20 rules and Company B on 16. Both are judged twice on every rule that applies.
Look at what the failures did: nothing. The four rules Company A failed added no points and took none away, and the same for Company B. No rule can drag down another, and the score cannot go below zero. The other thing to notice is that the two were divided by different numbers, 20 and 16. That is deliberate: a bank is not judged on rules that make no sense for a bank, so the fair test is the one that drops them.
What it tells you about the business
It tells you how much of the measurable case for a durable business this company clears, in the newest quarter and across five years at once. It says nothing about the price you would pay for it.
Why it changes
A new filing crosses a level the company used to miss, so a half point becomes a full one. Or the five-year average finally catches up with a business that turned good.
The newest quarter slips under a level, or a strong old quarter drops out of the five-year window and a weak one replaces it.
Half of every rule is a five-year test, so the score is slow on purpose. A company that improved last year keeps scoring half points until its average agrees.
The trap
Nothing is ever subtracted. There are no negative points. A clear fail costs the half point the passing half would have earned, and that is its entire effect.
It is not a price. A company can pass nearly every rule and still be far too dear to buy.
The levels are cliffs. The gross margin rule passes at 40%, which treats 39.5% and 40.5% as different worlds on a business that is the same either way.
Two scores out of different numbers of rules are still both out of 100. A high score on few rules leaned on each of them harder.
Where you see it in MarginX
Open the chips before you read the score. They show which rules were dropped, which passed on one half only, and the level each one had to clear.