Margin vs History and Rating
Is this multiple high or low for this particular company?
A multiple on its own says what the market charges today. Set it against the same company's average over the last five years and it says something else: whether the market has changed its mind. That gap is the company measured against itself.
The formula
Current multiple against its own five year average
- The current multiple: The multiple as it stands today, for example a P/E of 18.
- The five year average: The same multiple averaged over that company's last five years, which is twenty quarters.
- The gap: How far today sits above or below that average, written as a percentage.
Example
Two companies trading on exactly the same P/E today. Company A has always been cheap. Company B used to be expensive.
The same multiple, opposite readings. Company A is being asked to pay half as much again as it usually costs. Company B is on sale against its own five years. A comparison that saw only today's 18 would treat these two as the same company. The level and the gap are two different questions, and both are worth asking.
What it tells you about the business
It tells you whether the market has changed its mind about this company, which the raw multiple cannot. A company is the only fair comparison for itself, because its industry, its debt and its accounting choices are all held still.
Why it changes
Today's multiple rose while the five year average barely moved, which is usually the price.
Today's multiple fell, or a very high year finally dropped out of the five year window.
The average itself drifts as old years leave it, so a gap can close with nothing happening today. Read the two numbers side by side rather than the gap alone.
The trap
Cheap against its own history is not cheap. A company that was overpriced for five years can be merely less overpriced now.
The gap can move because profit collapsed, which lifts the current multiple and makes the company look dear when it has actually got worse.
A percentage hides the size of the numbers behind it. A 25% gap means something different on a P/E of 8 than on a P/E of 60.
Where you see it in MarginX
In the screener each of the five multiples carries the same four columns: the current value, the 5-Year Avg, the Margin vs History between them, and a Rating, which scores that gap from 0 to 100. On the company page the gap is labelled vs Avg, and its score carries one word: Cheap at 70 and above, Fair from 40, Expensive below that.