Having trouble? Click to reload

Overview

What is actually on the screen, and what is each number claiming?

Everything in this chapter is about the screen rather than about finance. Every metric is drawn three ways and given a place in a queue. On top of that sit two scores: the DCA Score, the share of 21 quality rules a company passes, and the Valuation Score, where its price sits against our main comparison pool and against its own past. Neither score is an estimate of what a company is worth.

Every metric, three ways and a place in a queue

A metric is never shown as one figure. Current is the newest twelve months, Average is the mean of the last 20 quarterly readings and Trend is the direction across those same 20. A toggle beside them swaps the figure itself for its rating, a place from 0 to 100 against our main comparison pool.

The industry median is drawn next to the figure as well. It is there for your eyes, and it feeds no score.

Two scores, two questions

The DCA Score is built from the business: margins, debt, what it earns on what it owns, whether profit turns into cash. Every rule that applies is judged twice, on the newest quarter and on the five-year average, and the score is the share of those rules that went the company's way.

The Valuation Score is built from price. Five multiples, each read as it stands and again as the gap against its own five-year average, each turned into a rank against one pool. High means cheap, low means dear.

A company can score 90 on one and 20 on the other. A strong business at a punchy price, and a weak business going for nothing, are both ordinary results.

What we do not do

There is no discounted cash flow model behind either score, no fair value and no price target. We say where a price sits among thousands of others and against its own history, which is a smaller claim, and one you can check.

There is no forecast either. Every figure comes from filings that have already happened, plus a traded price.

The one textbook expected return we show, the CAPM number beside beta, is a reference point. It feeds neither score.

How the two scores are connected

They are not two independent opinions. The DCA Score sets a quality multiplier inside the Valuation Score, on a straight line from 0.70 at the bottom to 1.30 at the top. That is why a cheap weak business does not score as well as a cheap strong one.

So when both scores move the same way, part of that is by construction.

The seven pages after this one

First the two that sit under every metric: the three columns, then what a rating is and what the industry median is doing beside it.

Then one page per score, with the arithmetic in the open.

Then the readings that are not about the company's own accounts: how well its country is run, how much its share has moved, and which parts of the economy its results have followed.

Then the two honest ones. Why more than half the companies we hold show no score at all, and what none of these numbers can tell you.

MarginX is a software research tool and data publisher, not an investment adviser. Contact: support@marginx.biz